After a trial, Rosie Rossitto-Canty was found to have intentionally "'keyed'" the hood of Paul E. Canty's car.
(According to Paul's testimony, Rosie was in "'plain sight'" when she purportedly perpetrated the damage.)
After the New York County Civil Court awarded Paul $633.37, Rosie appealed to the Appellate Term, First Department.
Although Rosie continued to profess innocence, the AT1 deferred to the lower court's assessment of each party's credibility and upheld the award.
Looks like that Canty couldn't find the key to winning that case!
To view a copy of the Appellate Term's decision, please use this link: Canty v. Rossitto-Canty